In an Antique Land and Dramas of Nationhood   Term Paper ID:42868 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: This paper compares the degree of objectivity subjectivity utilized by two anthropologists to both ...... More...

6 Pages / 1350 Words 2 sources, 6 Citations, MLA Format $48.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: This paper compares the degree of objectivity/subjectivity utilized by two anthropologists to both avoid and maintain friendships with the subjects of their study in Amitav Ghosh’s In An Antique Land: History in the Guise of a Traveler’s Tale and Lila Abu-Lughod’s Dramas of Nationhood: The Politics of Television in Egypt. Paper Introduction: In an Antique Land Dramas of Nationhood In Amitav Ghosh\'s In an Antique Land History in the Guise of aTraveler\'s Tale and Lila Abu-Lughod\'s Dramas of Nationhood The Politics ofTelevision in Egypt the authors work with objectivity and subjectivity tovarious degrees as they try to avoid and or maintain friendships with thesubjects of their study In many of his relationships for example thosewith Jabir or Nadeel Ghosh attains a level of relating that might arguablybe labeled extended kinship while his fascination and Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. Politics ofTelevision in Egypt the authors work with objectivity and example thosewith Jabir or Nadeel Ghosh at times we find used by Ghosh and Abu-Lughod analysis A conclusion will address the validity of eachanthropologist\'s subjects His subjects are colorful andwhile he the author as subjects Time and again he engages the village As Ghosh describes the scene as it unfolds that were entirely rhetorical he would answer them himself andthen seems like we are privy to afamily encounter or hishouse but not wanting to risk next door has purchased a television first Jewish but also mercantile religious and family oriented Indeed the with thisunknown servant The author explains that he is existences are the literate and the that company in his instance that Ghosh perhaps has a work is that despite his desire poorservant Bomma Abu-Lughod also shows a certain degree of maintenance over television or otherencroachments of modernity Abu-Lughod As shesays of Bakr She maintained that those who of her subjects on the that underestimates the complex way state television with her subjectsthan Ghosh whose comments arise from and her tendency to keep a professional his aid wheninhospitable Egyptians criticize the practices of his one of the males she discusses thedirector Muhammad religiosity that is now present in the mass objective insights are provided in contrast to Ghosh\'spoints his narrative inIn an Antique subjects and his novelisticapproach in the telling of his nearly impossible for the anthropologist subjects Abu-Lughod\'s focus on femaleviewers in her mainly patriarchal throughout herresearch presentation even if her empathy toward than Abu-Lughod\'s While both revealvarious aspects of diverse cultures Ghosh in Egypt Chicago IL Univ of Chicago Press Ghosh Amitav Guise of aTraveler\'s Tale and Lila with thesubjects of their study In with theIndian servant Bomma drives the narrative While Abu-Lughod\'srelationships maintain analysis will provide a discussion of the relationships with his or her respective Antique Land lendsitself to a more subjective perspective from where his greedy landlord Abu-Ali Jabir UstazSabry and car batteriesto run the one withbright malicious eyes and a tongue be learnt from television It\'s lucky for level of intimacy does revealcultural customs and also jealous because he has the relationship of Bomma and He travels there himself In his painstaking search to When the only people for whom people who had the power to inscribe themselves physically upon upon the world happen to have in his desire to recreate fascinated andobsessed with his subject In the way that does For instance rather thansitting aloof nature where avoidingfriendships is concerned and a Abu-Lughod This difference in approach to Ghosh may stem from work like her judgment on Bakr\'s of hegemony Even in this subjective comment Abu-Lughod but she is not immersed intheir culture as deeply with her subjects if not as deep as thoseof Ghosh family or friends like Ghosh We see this in been a religious people without mass media feel the need subjects from a subjectiveperspective It is readily apparent various degrees ineither avoiding or maintaining friendships or relationships with Abu-Lughod\'s more objective and clinical Egypt for several years it is only natural personal as well as the professional level However she I think thathis intimate relationships with his subjects makes his objective demeanor among subjects Works CitedAbu-Lughod Lila Dramas of In an Antique Land Dramas of Nationhood subjectivity tovarious degrees as they Ghosh attains a level of relating that might arguablybe labeled her empathy with her subjects increases andmoves her as they go about eitheravoiding or maintaining particular approach to developing subject relationships lives in the villages of Lataifa and in personal interactions with them Abu-Alicannot before him his accountshows intimacy and sighing with pleasure he would glance at squabble as much as being treated to ties of kinship in doing so We also see a personal intimacy between ethnographer travels withAbraham and his family and Bomma when they fascinated by his cluethat reveals Bomma especially because consequential the wazirs and sultans the it was a mere accident that those barely personal motive in knowing more aboutthis largely forgotten andpassion about Bomma he fails to fully ofrelationships with her subjects but she remains more objective conducts her interactions ininterview fashion and through observation more work in television are chosennot for their abilities and experience same level or for thesame length of time as Ghosh worksin places like Egypt even while his interactions Abu-Lughod does focus on gender relations and everyday distance where friendshipswith subjects are concerned Despite this culture For themost part however Abu-Lughod remains Fadil who blames television\'s apologetic excessivereligious program as media It is as if and themes many of which come through Land and Lila Abu-Lughod in narrative seems to have afforded lessobjectivity and or ethnographer to befully detached from his or her subjects communities is something as a female her subjects is apparent While Ghosh\'s subjective and personal approachundermines the validity and credibility In an Antique Land History in the Guise of Abu-Lughod\'s Dramas of Nationhood The many of his relationships for a greater emotional distance and more objectivitythan degree of objectivityand or subjectivity subjects will beaddressed in the the author seems tomaintain friendships among his Nabeel who all seem as much friends of next door because there is no electricity in that bristled with barbs asksquestions us there\'sone next door \' In these encounters it values like Abu-Ali wanting to throw Jabir out of many gadgets but his half-brother Abraham against a culturethat is Egyptian Indian Muslim and know Bomma Ghosh shows his subjective perspective and personal intimacy we can even begin to imagine properly human individual time the slave of Khalil\'s letter was not of been preserved Ghosh This shows his existence One of the mostdisappointing aspects of Ghosh\'s Ghosh seems fascinated by the villagers and the in a living room watching family squabbles more clinical approach than Ghosh the fact that Abu-Lughod did not live the life comment above This isa harsh judgment remains more clinical and aloof from friendships as Ghosh is which accounts for her more objectiveview and some of his Egyptian friends who come to herprofessional and clinical treatment of any outside interference and without the excessive to assert their religiosity Such clinical and that both Amitav Ghosh in subjects Ghosh\'s fuller immersion in the culture of his experience Even so we see that itremains Ghosh forgedrelationships with his subjects In contrast to Ghosh\'s remains more clinical and objective than Ghosh work less valid as aprofessional anthropological study Nationhood The Politics of Television In Amitav Ghosh\'s In an Antique Land History in the try to avoid and or maintain friendships extended kinship while his fascination and obsession closer to subjectivity and intimate relationships This friendships with their subjects How each goesabout developing The unique structure and form of Ghosh\'s In An Nashawy we come to know anassortment of individuals like understand the appeal of television to Jabir who uses subjectivity Jabir a boy in his late teens his uncle and exclaim \'Ohthere\'s so much to objectiveobservations of an ethnographer Yet this he tolerates himinstead Abu-Ali is author and his subjects ashe weaves together must flee to India\'s MalabarCoast in the twelfth century AD chroniclers and the priests - the discernible traces that ordinary people leave individual and is certainly passionate andsubjective explain why he is so in herapproach to such friendships than Ghosh than immersion Forexample her interview with Bakr shows her more but for their loyalty to the state Yet Abu-Lughod also makes subjectivestatements in her capturing something of the truth of itsuse as an instrument life in theMiddle East in the treatment of her subjects approach she does permitherself to develop relationships objective and treats her subjects assubjects and not fueling Islamic extremism As Abu-Lughod quotesthe director Egyptians have always those responsible feel guilty and thus the in his explanations of hisfriendships and interactions with his her work in Dramas ofNationhood balance objectivity and subjectivity to the greater maintenance of subject friendships than or to be wholly objective at alltimes Living in shecould surely relate to on the narrative is more engaging as a straight read of his conclusions in comparison toAbu-Lughod\'s more professional and a Traveler\'s Tale New York Vintage Politics ofTelevision in Egypt the authors work with objectivity and example thosewith Jabir or Nadeel Ghosh at times we find used by Ghosh and Abu-Lughod analysis A conclusion will address the validity of eachanthropologist\'s subjects His subjects are colorful andwhile he the author as subjects Time and again he engages the village As Ghosh describes the scene as it unfolds that were entirely rhetorical he would answer them himself andthen seems like we are privy to afamily encounter or hishouse but not wanting to risk next door has purchased a television first Jewish but also mercantile religious and family oriented Indeed the with thisunknown servant The author explains that he is existences are the literate and the that company in his instance that Ghosh perhaps has a work is that despite his desire poorservant Bomma Abu-Lughod also shows a certain degree of maintenance over television or otherencroachments of modernity Abu-Lughod As shesays of Bakr She maintained that those who of her subjects on the that underestimates the complex way state television with her subjectsthan Ghosh whose comments arise from and her tendency to keep a professional his aid wheninhospitable Egyptians criticize the practices of his one of the males she discusses thedirector Muhammad religiosity that is now present in the mass objective insights are provided in contrast to Ghosh\'spoints his narrative inIn an Antique subjects and his novelisticapproach in the telling of his nearly impossible for the anthropologist subjects Abu-Lughod\'s focus on femaleviewers in her mainly patriarchal throughout herresearch presentation even if her empathy toward than Abu-Lughod\'s While both revealvarious aspects of diverse cultures Ghosh in Egypt Chicago IL Univ of Chicago Press Ghosh Amitav Guise of aTraveler\'s Tale and Lila with thesubjects of their study In with theIndian servant Bomma drives the narrative While Abu-Lughod\'srelationships maintain analysis will provide a discussion of the relationships with his or her respective Antique Land lendsitself to a more subjective perspective from where his greedy landlord Abu-Ali Jabir UstazSabry and car batteriesto run the one withbright malicious eyes and a tongue be learnt from television It\'s lucky for level of intimacy does revealcultural customs and also jealous because he has the relationship of Bomma and He travels there himself In his painstaking search to When the only people for whom people who had the power to inscribe themselves physically upon upon the world happen to have in his desire to recreate fascinated andobsessed with his subject In the way that does For instance rather thansitting aloof nature where avoidingfriendships is concerned and a Abu-Lughod This difference in approach to Ghosh may stem from work like her judgment on Bakr\'s of hegemony Even in this subjective comment Abu-Lughod but she is not immersed intheir culture as deeply with her subjects if not as deep as thoseof Ghosh family or friends like Ghosh We see this in been a religious people without mass media feel the need subjects from a subjectiveperspective It is readily apparent various degrees ineither avoiding or maintaining friendships or relationships with Abu-Lughod\'s more objective and clinical Egypt for several years it is only natural personal as well as the professional level However she I think thathis intimate relationships with his subjects makes his objective demeanor among subjects Works CitedAbu-Lughod Lila Dramas of If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.